Vox Populi Forum
I took the Bibles and Missionaries. I did misread the Barding Warhorse as Barding ... d'uhhhh.
If we end up in a New World of aborigines, we will need (or more correctly be very happy that we brought) horses and metal armor.
We took enough supplies to establish a colony. We may not be able to hold it and we may not be able to profit from it, but it's a start.
If we end up in a New World with an Asian power, we'll have to rely on our diplomatic skills. It's unlikely we'll be left to build a colony.
In the end, we have some things missing but the first bad flip of a card will create more losses.
Travelling to the New World is crazy dangerous and risky. We're going to have to maximize our chance for success and leverage our character advantages.