Well... Mostly scene for scene.
Message:Changing Ozymandius's plan from fake alien attack to frame Doctor Manhattan for a nuclear attack is a pretty big change.
Snyder did ok with 300 and Watchman because both are deconstructive stories. He failed at mainline DC because - and this is important - he doesn't LIKE mainline DC comics. I can find the interview where he says so. Like Snyder thinks Nolan's Batman trilogy should have begun with Bruce Wayne being gang raped in prison and thinks that Superman should be accidentally killing people left and right. Makes it difficult for him to make the characters inspiring and heroic. And he didn't.
And he's not a very good writer on his originals.
He knows how to move a camera, but uses too much slow motion. I suspect he's color blind because he grades everything so brown on brown.
Yours,
IronMike
17-Mar-2023