Yes, plot and characters the same in a different setting. Like one, probably like both, your choice to dissent.
Here's where I struggle? How can Abrams mess-up his versions of these classic stories? Wait I know the answer...because he's one of the pillars of the temple worshiped in the Age of Shoddy.
Next hypothetical: where are the barbarians, when you need them?
Scan the horizon while hanging on the Tree of Woe.